Oli Marmol claims it wouldn't be awkward if Nolan Arenado returns to the St. Louis Cardinals in 2026, but the roster math tells a different story. Bernie Miklasz breaks down why retaining Arenado creates an impossible logjam for young talent like JJ Wetherholt and explains how the manager's refusal to rest injured veterans has backfired.

","highlights","status","PUBLISHED","featuredImage","/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-12-12-25-544x306.jpg","seo",{"_370":866,"_867":868,"_869":870,"_898":899,"_900":863},"The Bernie Show: Don't Block Playing Time for Rising Star","excerpt","Oli Marmol claims it wouldn't be awkward if Nolan Arenado returns to the St. Louis Cardinals in 2026.","keyInfo",[871,875,879,883,886,889,892,895],{"_38":872,"_34":873,"_36":874},"Major League Baseball","league","major-league-baseball",{"_38":876,"_34":877,"_36":878},"St Louis Cardinals","team","st-louis-cardinals",{"_38":880,"_34":881,"_36":882},"Oli Marmol","player","oli-marmol",{"_38":884,"_34":881,"_36":885},"Chaim Bloom","chaim-bloom",{"_38":887,"_34":881,"_36":888},"Nolan Arenado","nolan-arenado",{"_38":890,"_34":881,"_36":891},"JJ Wetherholt","jj-wetherholt",{"_38":893,"_34":881,"_36":894},"Brendan Donovan","brendan-donovan",{"_38":896,"_34":881,"_36":897},"Nolan Gorman","nolan-gorman","contentLength",98,"defaultImage","pageViews","commentCount","0","categoryFilter",{"_906":907,"_908":909},"property","specs.tag","values",[910],"stl-sports-central","slugUrl","2025/12/12/the-bernie-show-12-12-25","lock",{"_915":53,"_916":-5,"_917":-5,"_918":-5},"isLocked","userName","userId","date","categoryId","userReactions",[],"reactionSummary",[],"feedPageHeading","feedPageHeadingLineTwo","feedPageTitle","feedPageDescription","feedPageLogo","hideFeedForum","prohibitComments","prohibitReactions","prohibitReactionsInComments","hideFeaturedImage","advancedOptions","feedBorderOverrideColor","feedBlurb","tag",[939,941,943,945,947,949,951,952,953,954,955,956,957,958,959],{"_7":937,"_728":940},"sports",{"_7":937,"_728":942},"missouri-sports",{"_7":937,"_728":944},"saint-louis-sports",{"_7":937,"_728":946},"saint-louis",{"_7":937,"_728":948},"st-louis",{"_7":937,"_728":950},"st-louis-sports",{"_7":937,"_728":910},{"_7":873,"_728":874},{"_7":877,"_728":878},{"_7":881,"_728":882},{"_7":881,"_728":885},{"_7":881,"_728":888},{"_7":881,"_728":891},{"_7":881,"_728":894},{"_7":881,"_728":897},"isPremium","isWarning","isTertiary","hasEmbed","types",[966],"video","videoInfo",{"_969":970},"url","https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amVsA7vfZkg","podcastInfo",{"_969":18},"relatedArticles",{"_15":975,"_976":977},[],"filters",[978],{"_906":907,"_908":979},[910],"thumbnail","/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-12-12-25-thumbnail.jpg","publishedOn","2025-12-12T20:36:00.000Z","featuredImageUrl","cacheKey","shstl_the-bernie-show-12-12-25","cachedOn","2026-04-02T09:00:22.359Z","contentBlocks",[991,997,1000,1002,1004],{"_34":992,"_15":993,"_996":18},"ad",{"_34":82,"_36":128,"_38":128,"_39":18,"_41":18,"_42":23,"_43":129,"_44":18,"_46":18,"_47":18,"_48":18,"_50":994,"_52":53,"_54":53,"_55":53,"_56":53,"_57":995},[],{"_59":18,"_60":18,"_61":18,"_62":18,"_63":18,"_64":18,"_65":18,"_66":18,"_68":18,"_69":18},"html",{"_34":998,"_996":999},"text","

",{"_34":998,"_996":1001},"

",{"_34":998,"_996":1003},"

",{"_34":998,"_996":1003},"metaSettings",{"_370":371,"_372":373,"_147":374,"_375":371,"_376":377,"_378":377,"_379":377,"_380":377,"_381":1007,"_390":391,"_392":18,"_393":377,"_394":377,"_395":377,"_396":397},{"_383":384,"_385":386,"_387":388,"_389":329},"sidebarSections",[1010,1104,1186],{"_162":1011,"_1014":1015,"_1016":1017,"_1018":1017,"_976":1019},{"_370":1012,"_372":18,"_1013":18},"Bernie Miklasz Written Content","image","articles",[],"desktopLayoutStyle","default","mobileLayoutStyle",[1020],{"_34":937,"_36":1021,"_1022":217,"_15":1023,"_1036":1037,"_908":1038,"_1102":45,"_964":1103},"bernie-miklasz","count",{"_36":1021,"_38":1024,"_854":-5,"_34":937,"_140":1025,"_1034":1035},"bernie miklasz",{"_142":1026,"_143":1027,"_147":-5,"_148":1029,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1030},"973aec08-a44b-4277-b40c-693f768934cd",{"_36":-5,"_7":1028,"_146":-5},"Specification",[],{"_154":1031,"_156":1032,"_158":1032,"_159":1033},"2025-03-23T14:57:49.169Z","9c11c01e-d312-4b5a-a115-bf834a35f1e0","2025-03-23T14:57:49.171Z","contentTypes",[840],"load","preload",[1039,1060,1074,1088],{"_1013":1040,"_842":1041,"_911":1042,"_937":1024,"_918":1043,"_982":1044,"_850":1045,"_856":1048,"_370":1049,"_392":1050,"_867":1050,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1052,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1054,"_922":1055,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1056,"_844":1052,"_967":1057,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/bernie/bernie-central-rev-544x306.jpg","bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-1-26","/2026/04/01/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-1-26","2026-04-01T16:01:56.419Z","2026-04-01T16:16:00.000Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1046,"_854":1047},"berniemiklasz","/avatars/berniemiklasz.jpg",[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Short Story of Five Cardinal Games","McGreevy was the only Cardinals starter who put away hitters via strikeouts with any regularity.","viewCount","3fc55d6d-c76c-49e0-886b-23d0ed2b696b","isLiveFile",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},"externalUrl","subHeadings",{"_1013":1040,"_842":1061,"_911":1062,"_937":1024,"_918":1063,"_982":1064,"_850":1065,"_856":1066,"_370":1067,"_392":1068,"_867":1068,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1069,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1070,"_922":1071,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1072,"_844":1069,"_967":1073,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-31-26","/2026/03/31/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-31-26","2026-03-31T22:09:11.974Z","2026-03-31T22:25:40.914Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1046,"_854":1047},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Don't Rush Jordan Walker Into Cleanup -- Marmol Is Right to Stay Patient","Cardinals manager Oli Marmol will stay with Masyn Winn as his No. 4 hitter in the lineup, even if the very early results are underwhelming. Nothing about this, however, is set in Missouri granite down at the St. Francois Mountains, in the southeastern part of our state. ","fb5b1a33-d7c4-410a-9cf0-d2bb25d32c79",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1040,"_842":1075,"_911":1076,"_937":1024,"_918":1077,"_982":1078,"_850":1079,"_856":1080,"_370":1081,"_392":1082,"_867":1082,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1083,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1084,"_922":1085,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1086,"_844":1083,"_967":1087,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-30-26","/2026/03/30/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-30-26","2026-03-30T22:01:39.045Z","2026-03-30T22:22:00.000Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1046,"_854":1047},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Opening Series Donnybrook","These Cardinals have some brashness in their genetic makeup.","9ef87399-19d2-48f2-bcb9-2555cac7960a",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1040,"_842":1089,"_911":1090,"_937":1024,"_918":1091,"_982":1092,"_850":1093,"_856":1094,"_370":1095,"_392":1096,"_867":1096,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1097,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1098,"_922":1099,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1100,"_844":1097,"_967":1101,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-27-26","/2026/03/27/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-27-26","2026-03-27T20:38:23.237Z","2026-03-27T20:56:00.000Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1046,"_854":1047},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Youth Served On Opening Day","In the Cardinals’ 9-7 Opening Day comeback over the Rays, the youth-led \"rebuild\" lineup was almost entirely composed of homegrown talent.","406944a5-b5c7-497b-83e2-686d0b4c19c5",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},"skip",[840],{"_162":1105,"_1014":1106,"_1016":1017,"_1018":1017,"_976":1107},{"_370":310,"_372":18,"_1013":18},[],[1108],{"_34":937,"_36":1109,"_1022":217,"_15":1110,"_1036":1037,"_908":1121,"_1102":45,"_964":1185},"gambling-fantasy",{"_854":-5,"_34":937,"_36":1109,"_38":1111,"_1112":53,"_140":1113,"_1034":1120},"gambling fantasy ","isHidden",{"_142":1114,"_143":1115,"_147":-5,"_148":1116,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1117},"3ce1eb25-10fd-4293-bffe-ac02c4d2ba50",{"_36":-5,"_7":1028,"_146":-5},[],{"_154":1118,"_156":157,"_158":157,"_159":1119},"2025-02-06T16:09:52.564Z","2025-02-06T16:09:54.032Z",[840],[1122,1140,1155,1170],{"_1013":1123,"_842":1124,"_911":1125,"_937":1111,"_918":1126,"_982":1127,"_850":1128,"_856":1132,"_370":1133,"_392":1134,"_867":1134,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1135,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1136,"_922":1137,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1138,"_844":1135,"_967":1139,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/random/slu-vs-dayton-544x306.jpg","slu-billikens-dayton-flyers-march-14-2026","/2026/03/13/slu-billikens-dayton-flyers-march-14-2026","2026-03-14T01:56:07.727Z","2026-03-14T02:04:22.743Z",{"_38":1129,"_36":1130,"_854":1131},"Eric Sontag","esontag","/avatars/esontag.jpg",[],"SLU vs Dayton Betting Preview: Billikens, Flyers Play Rubber Match","Saint Louis and Dayton meet for the third time this season in the Atlantic 10 semifinals Saturday, with a trip to the conference title game on the line.","e24821e4-a0ce-49e5-af38-9b71c872de54",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1141,"_842":1142,"_911":1143,"_937":1111,"_918":1144,"_982":1145,"_850":1146,"_856":1147,"_370":1148,"_392":1149,"_867":1149,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1150,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1151,"_922":1152,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1153,"_844":1150,"_967":1154,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/random/slu-vs-george-washington-544x306.jpg","slu-billikens-george-washington-revolutionaries-march-13-2026","/2026/03/12/slu-billikens-george-washington-revolutionaries-march-13-2026","2026-03-13T03:11:24.157Z","2026-03-13T03:23:34.123Z",{"_38":1129,"_36":1130,"_854":1131},[],"SLU vs George Washington Betting Preview: Can Billikens Right The Ship?","Top-seed Saint Louis faces George Washington in the Atlantic 10 quarterfinals Friday morning. The Billikens look to avoid an upset and move one step closer to the A10 title.","a4a39c84-577c-4774-a372-ae83c4be1b20",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1156,"_842":1157,"_911":1158,"_937":1111,"_918":1159,"_982":1160,"_850":1161,"_856":1162,"_370":1163,"_392":1164,"_867":1164,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1165,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1166,"_922":1167,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1168,"_844":1165,"_967":1169,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/random/mizzou-vs-kentucky-544x306.jpg","mizzou-tigers-kentucky-wildcats-march-12-2026","/2026/03/12/mizzou-tigers-kentucky-wildcats-march-12-2026","2026-03-12T05:34:47.147Z","2026-03-12T05:47:43.476Z",{"_38":1129,"_36":1130,"_854":1131},[],"Mizzou vs Kentucky Betting Preview: Tigers Look To Beat Cats Again","Missouri faces Kentucky in the SEC Tournament second round Thursday in Nashville. The winner advances to face top-seeded Florida in the quarterfinals.","5e256c07-6099-413c-b77b-5fc3def8a255",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1171,"_842":1172,"_911":1173,"_937":1111,"_918":1174,"_982":1175,"_850":1176,"_856":1177,"_370":1178,"_392":1179,"_867":1179,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1180,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1181,"_922":1182,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1183,"_844":1180,"_967":1184,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/random/blues-vs-anaheim-544x306.jpg","st-louis-blues-anaheim-ducks-march-8-2026","/2026/03/08/st-louis-blues-anaheim-ducks-march-8-2026","2026-03-08T19:03:20.731Z","2026-03-08T19:09:12.369Z",{"_38":1129,"_36":1130,"_854":1131},[],"Blues vs Ducks Betting Preview: Streaking Blues Head To Anaheim","The St. Louis Blues visit the Anaheim Ducks on Sunday night. St. Louis enters on a three-game winning streak while Anaheim holds the top spot in the Pacific Division.","c9111922-e5d6-41b6-878b-d0057cf636db",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},[840],{"_162":1187,"_1014":1188,"_1016":1017,"_1018":1017,"_976":1189},{"_370":876,"_372":18,"_1013":18},[],[1190],{"_34":877,"_36":878,"_1102":190,"_1022":217,"_15":1191,"_1036":1037,"_908":1200,"_964":1274},{"_854":-5,"_34":877,"_36":878,"_38":876,"_1112":53,"_140":1192,"_1034":1199},{"_142":1193,"_143":1194,"_147":-5,"_148":1195,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1196},"4c4a795a-2dd7-46d4-926b-9a1a3c87ac55",{"_36":-5,"_7":1028,"_146":-5},[],{"_154":1197,"_156":157,"_158":157,"_159":1198},"2025-01-24T15:00:01.364Z","2025-01-24T15:00:02.715Z",[840],[1201,1218,1238,1257],{"_1013":1202,"_842":1203,"_911":1204,"_937":371,"_918":1205,"_982":1206,"_850":1207,"_856":1208,"_370":1209,"_392":1210,"_867":1210,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_964":1211,"_36":1212,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1213,"_922":1214,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1215,"_844":1212,"_967":1216,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-3-31-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-3-31-26","/2026/03/31/the-bernie-show-3-31-26","2026-03-31T19:45:28.936Z","2026-03-31T19:49:00.000Z",{"_38":852,"_36":853,"_854":855},[],"The Bernie Show: Walker and Gorman Hot Starts","The Cardinals offense might depend entirely on whether Walker and Gorman can sustain it.",[966],"80fb5c70-8225-4fdb-b234-cb586a748113",[],[],{},{"_969":1217},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tFJF5Gb-xs",{"_1013":1219,"_842":1220,"_911":1221,"_937":876,"_918":1222,"_982":1223,"_1224":1225,"_850":1226,"_856":1230,"_370":1231,"_392":1232,"_867":1232,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1233,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1234,"_922":1235,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1236,"_844":1233,"_967":1237,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/cardinals/jj-walk-off-ice-bath-544x306.jpg","cardinals-offense-does-not-quit-in-opening-series-win-over-rays","/2026/03/31/cardinals-offense-does-not-quit-in-opening-series-win-over-rays","2026-03-31T16:23:09.638Z","2026-03-31T18:54:51.414Z","photoCredit","Credit: Jeff Curry-Imagn Images",{"_38":1227,"_36":1228,"_854":1229},"Hunter Mulholland","huntermulholland","/avatars/huntermulholland.jpg",[],"Cardinals Offense Does Not Quit In Opening Series Win Over Rays","The St. Louis Cardinals won their opening series of the season over the Tampa Bay Rays with an offense firing on all cylinders.","eb2bb723-1232-4b91-b1c5-e39f19a22bd4",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1239,"_842":1240,"_911":1241,"_937":876,"_918":1242,"_982":1243,"_1224":1244,"_850":1245,"_856":1249,"_370":1250,"_392":1251,"_867":1251,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_36":1252,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1253,"_922":1254,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1255,"_844":1252,"_967":1256,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/cardinals/usatsi_28622672_168416177_lowres-544x306.jpg","st-louis-cardinals-kyle-leahy-builds-up-first-start","/2026/03/31/st-louis-cardinals-kyle-leahy-builds-up-first-start","2026-03-31T16:04:53.635Z","2026-03-31T16:31:50.105Z","Jeff Curry-Imagn Images",{"_38":1246,"_36":1247,"_854":1248},"Brenden Schaeffer","brendenschaeffer","/avatars/brendenschaeffer.jpg",[],"Kyle Leahy ran out of steam -- but first outing was solid building block for Cardinals starter","During his start on Monday night at Busch Stadium, Cardinals starter Kyle Leahy logged more innings than in any other game appearance of his MLB career.","311e1c04-57d3-4dad-bf32-bb4265845cc3",[],[],{},{"_969":-5},{"_1013":1258,"_842":1259,"_911":1260,"_937":371,"_918":1261,"_982":1262,"_850":1263,"_856":1264,"_370":1265,"_392":1266,"_867":1266,"_960":53,"_961":53,"_962":53,"_1051":190,"_902":903,"_964":1267,"_36":1268,"_417":840,"_1053":53,"_920":1269,"_922":1270,"_930":53,"_931":53,"_932":53,"_934":1271,"_844":1268,"_967":1272,"_1058":18,"_1059":-5,"_936":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-3-30-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-3-30-26","/2026/03/30/the-bernie-show-3-30-26","2026-03-30T16:07:32.739Z","2026-03-30T16:11:00.000Z",{"_38":852,"_36":853,"_854":855},[],"The Bernie Show: Youthful Exuberance Forms Identity","From Jordan Walker’s breakout signs to JJ Wetherholt making history, this young Cardinals roster might be ahead of schedule. ",[966],"ceffdc97-ae96-45ff-ae7f-3f8c61b756a5",[],[],{},{"_969":1273},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQMoBDSZmcQ",[840],"playerData","actionData","errors"]

The Bernie Show: Don't Block Playing Time for Rising Star

REDBIRD REVIEW: Short Story of Five Cardinal Games

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 1, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Don't Rush Jordan Walker Into Cleanup -- Marmol Is Right to Stay Patient

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 31, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Opening Series Donnybrook

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 30, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Youth Served On Opening Day

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 27, 2026

SLU vs Dayton Betting Preview: Billikens, Flyers Play Rubber Match

By Eric Sontag

Mar 13, 2026

SLU vs George Washington Betting Preview: Can Billikens Right The Ship?

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Mizzou vs Kentucky Betting Preview: Tigers Look To Beat Cats Again

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Blues vs Ducks Betting Preview: Streaking Blues Head To Anaheim

By Eric Sontag

Mar 8, 2026

The Bernie Show: Walker and Gorman Hot Starts

By HUB STAFF

Mar 31, 2026

Cardinals Offense Does Not Quit In Opening Series Win Over Rays

By Hunter Mulholland

Mar 31, 2026

Kyle Leahy ran out of steam -- but first outing was solid building block for Cardinals starter

By Brenden Schaeffer

Mar 31, 2026

The Bernie Show: Youthful Exuberance Forms Identity

By HUB STAFF

Mar 30, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Short Story of Five Cardinal Games

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 1, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Don't Rush Jordan Walker Into Cleanup -- Marmol Is Right to Stay Patient

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 31, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Opening Series Donnybrook

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 30, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Youth Served On Opening Day

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 27, 2026

SLU vs Dayton Betting Preview: Billikens, Flyers Play Rubber Match

By Eric Sontag

Mar 13, 2026

SLU vs George Washington Betting Preview: Can Billikens Right The Ship?

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Mizzou vs Kentucky Betting Preview: Tigers Look To Beat Cats Again

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Blues vs Ducks Betting Preview: Streaking Blues Head To Anaheim

By Eric Sontag

Mar 8, 2026

The Bernie Show: Walker and Gorman Hot Starts

By HUB STAFF

Mar 31, 2026

Cardinals Offense Does Not Quit In Opening Series Win Over Rays

By Hunter Mulholland

Mar 31, 2026

Kyle Leahy ran out of steam -- but first outing was solid building block for Cardinals starter

By Brenden Schaeffer

Mar 31, 2026

The Bernie Show: Youthful Exuberance Forms Identity

By HUB STAFF

Mar 30, 2026